CBCA 3760
Board: CBCA
Agency: Department of Health and Human Services
Appellant: Smith Management Construction, Inc. and BRC Lease Company, L.L.C.
Date: 2018-11-05
Outcome: settled
THIS OPINION WAS INITIALLY ISSUED UNDER PROTECTIVE ORDER AND
IS BEING RELEASED TO THE PUBLIC IN ITS ENTIRETY ON
NOVEMBER 14, 2018
GRANTED IN PART; DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE IN PART: November 5, 2018
CBCA 3760, 4822, 5281
SMITH MANAGEMENT CONSTRUCTION, INC.,
and
BRC LEASE COMPANY, L.L.C.,
Appellants,
v.
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES,
Respondent.
Richard A. DeTar of McAllister, DeTar, Showalter & Walker, Easton, MD, counsel
for Appellants.
Richard G. Bergeron, Office of the General Counsel, Department of Health and
Human Services, Washington, DC, counsel for Respondent.
Before Board Judges BEARDSLEY, DRUMMOND, and ZISCHKAU.
BEARDSLEY, Board Judge.
CBCA 3760, CBCA 4822, and CBCA 5281 were filed and docketed on October 15,
2013, September 29, 2014, and October 23, 2014, respectively. The parties have reached a
settlement resolving all three appeals.
CBCA 3760, 4822, 5281 2
On October 31, 2018, pursuant to Board Rule 25(b) (48 CFR 6101.25(b) (2018)) and
the terms of a settlement agreement, the parties jointly moved for a judgment in CBCA 5281
in the amount of $325,000, to be paid to Smith Management Construction, Inc. (on whose
behalf BRC Lease Company, L.L.C. passed through its claim). In a decision dated
January 24, 2017, the Board ruled that it possessed subject matter jurisdiction to decide
CBCA 5281. Appellants have waived all further rights to recover interest, attorney fees,
costs, or expenses incurred in conjunction with the appeals. In addition, the parties stated
that no party will seek reconsideration of, seek relief from, or appeal the Boardâs decision.
The parties also request dismissal of CBCA 3760 and CBCA 4822 with prejudice.
Decision
Pursuant to the partiesâ joint motion for entry of decision by stipulation, the Board
GRANTS CBCA 5281 IN PART. Appellants are awarded a total of $325,000, this amount
to be paid to Smith Management Construction, Inc. CBCA 3760 and CBCA 4822 are
DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE.
Erica S. Beardsley
ERICA S. BEARDSLEY
Board Judge
We concur:
___Jerome M. Drummond Jonathan D. Zischkau
JEROME M. DRUMMOND JONATHAN D. ZISCHKAU
Board Judge Board Judge